Following up with new patient enquiries at a dental office
A new patient enquiry is worth years and arrives at nine in the evening from somebody messaging three practices. What the first reply should answer, what must never be asked by text, and the three-step follow-up that then stops.
Sohail Safdar · · 5 min read
A new patient enquiry is the most valuable message a dental practice receives and the easiest one to lose.
Three things make it different from every other enquiry that arrives.
The value is the relationship, not the appointment. Somebody joining for a cleaning returns twice a year, brings a family, accepts treatment over time, and refers the neighbour with the same problem. A missed enquiry is not a missed cleaning.
They are shopping. Most people looking for a new dentist contact more than one practice, usually in the same sitting.
They write outside office hours. People deal with "I should find a dentist" in the evening, which means the practice that answers in the evening is competing against two unread messages rather than two other replies.
The first reply: answer, then ask one thing
"Yes, we are in-network with Delta Dental PPO. Are you looking for a cleaning and checkup, or is something bothering you?"
Two halves, both doing work.
Answer what they asked. Usually insurance, and this is where practices create problems for themselves later: say which plans you participate in, from a list you maintain, and nothing about what their plan will cover. A practice that is out-of-network but files claims as a courtesy can say "yes, we work with Delta" truthfully and produce a dispute at the billing desk. An AI receptionist for a dental office separates that question into the three different questions it actually is.
Then ask the one thing that routes the enquiry. Routine or something hurting. If something hurts, that is a same-day conversation with a person and nothing automated should be deciding anything about it. If it is routine, the booking link or an offer to have the front desk call.
What to ask, and what belongs in the form
Ask by text: new or existing, routine or urgent, which insurance plan, preferred days.
Do not ask by text: medical history, Social Security number, a photograph of an insurance card, anything clinical.
Those belong in your intake forms, where they are collected properly and stored properly. A text thread is read on a bus by whoever is sitting next to it and sits in a backup indefinitely, and for a practice this is a regulatory question rather than a stylistic one. HIPAA and texting patients covers the practical rules.
The four things you can ask are enough to route the enquiry and book the appointment. Everything else is paperwork pretending to be urgent.
Who owns it
One named person. Usually the front desk lead or a treatment coordinator, with the enquiry on their list and a due date attached.
Not a shared inbox. Three people reading the same enquiry produces zero replies, because each assumes another has it, and that is not a motivation problem: a shared inbox without assignment is an audience rather than a queue.
This single decision determines whether follow-up happens at all, which makes it more important than any wording below it.
The follow-up, three contacts then stop
The first reply, as above, as fast as possible.
Next day, if they did not book.
"Hi Maria, following up. Would you like me to find you a time for a new patient visit? We have Thursday morning or Friday afternoon."
Specific times rather than an invitation to propose some. A question somebody can answer in one word.
Later that week, carrying something useful.
"Hi Maria, in case it helps: a first visit here is an exam, X-rays and a cleaning, about an hour, and we will confirm anything your plan covers before you come in."
That removes the two things that actually stop people booking a first dental appointment, which are not knowing how long it takes and not knowing what it will cost.
Then stop. They know where you are. A fourth message from a healthcare provider reads as pressure, and the impression it leaves is worse than the booking it was chasing.
The appointment after the booking
Worth one section, because a new patient who books and does not arrive is a worse outcome than one who never booked: you held the slot.
First appointments no-show more than repeats, reliably, because arriving somewhere new is harder than people expect. So a new patient's first appointment is the one that most needs the day-before reminder, and the reminder is the one that most needs the practical detail: where to park, which door, what to bring, how long it will take.
Reducing no-shows with reminders covers the wording. The relevant point here is that the follow-up work does not end at the booking.
What to measure
- New patient enquiries per week, by channel.
- How many booked.
- Time to first reply, split by inside and outside opening hours, because they are different problems and one average hides both.
- How many of the booked ones arrived.
If enquiries are healthy and bookings are not, the problem is the reply or the follow-up rather than the marketing. If bookings are healthy and arrivals are not, the problem is the reminder. Those two conclusions get confused constantly, and the split above is what separates them.
In Frontiva
Enquiries from every channel land in one inbox and can be assigned, so the named-owner rule above is held by the software rather than by a convention. A lead carries an owner and a follow-up task with a due date, which is what makes the next-day message happen on a day when the practice is busy.
The assistant answers from the facts you approved, which for this purpose means your participating plan list and your published new-patient prices, in your wording. Anything clinical or urgent is handed to a person before an answer is attempted, by a check that runs ahead of the knowledge lookup and cannot be talked round by the message it is reading.
A waiting enquiry shows how long it has waited against your own target, measured in open hours, so an enquiry that arrived at 9pm is not reported as having waited all night. That matters for this trade specifically, because most new patient enquiries arrive when the practice is shut, and a target that marked all of them as breached would be a target nobody looked at twice.
The three-step follow-up is one of the built-in automations, and its exit condition is checked before every step, so a patient who books after the first message never receives the second.